Training Collars In 2019 – How to Choose The Best Training Collar?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The topic of controversy and debate ‘dog training collars’ has been around for a very long time to help pet parents discipline their beloved dogs. The reason for so much controversy is the fact that dog training collars have a shock system that is considered inhumane.

To aid my other fellow pet parents, I have spent a considerable amount of time identifying the most effective yet gentle dog training collars. And in this post, I will analyze in detail about the best training collars for dogs from my perspective.

Quick Comparison: Top Dog Training Collars

Training CollarQualityOur Rating
Petrainer PET998DBB2A
PetTech PT0Z1A-
SportDOG Brand 425
Educator E-CollarB+
PetSafe Training CollarA

Bird’s Eye View: What You Should Look for?

Shock collars or dog training collars are often confused for punishment and reprimand. The sole purpose of a shock collar is to prevent and curb undesirable behaviors by associating it with an unpleasant sensation felt by your dog. This in no way causes prolonged physical harm and a strain in your relationship with him. Having said that finding a good dog training collar requires a quality check on a few parameters, which are as follows:

Dog Training Collars in 2019 - How to Choose The Best Training Collar?

1) Modes

When looking for a good dog training collar, always search for the one with the maximum amount of modes and settings. Training collars feature several settings like vibration, warning beep, and the actual shock. It is imperative that there must a variety of shock intensities so that your dog can understand the level of discipline.

Many pet parents feel safer when there is a warning beep before triggering the shock. This also acts as a good window for you to reinforce a command, as your dog would know what’s to come if he continues to misbehave. Different training modes with a customizable level are where you should primarily focus.

2) Safety

This is every pet parent’s obvious concern. When there is an electric shock involved, you need to be sure about the repercussions of any mishap. Having an added ingenious protect mode in a dog training collar is a win-win. Several collars offer auto-protect in their collar design to be on the lookout for that. This will pacify your worries.

3) Transmitter Range

When your targeted behavior is preventing your pet dog from running past a certain boundary is when you need to understand a training collar’s transmitter range. These dog training collars with GPS help the system in identifying when to initiate the shock to prevent your dog from leaving the designated boundary.

Now the work here is simple. If you have a backyard or a lawn for your furry friend to play in, then you definitely require a higher transmitter range. In case your house’s outer perimeter is small then your purpose will suffice in a smaller transmitter range.

4) Affordability

Do not get mislead by the idea that expensive collars will serve more quality. I advise you having a pre-set budget and then finding a good product under it. For some dogs, even the most expensive dog training collars won’t fit comfortably, whereas an excessively cheap training collar can fit like a glove. So, you don’t necessarily have to burn a hole in your pocket in order to procure an effective dog training collar.

5) Battery & Lasting Time

Like every other electrical appliance, you should find a dog training collar with a lasting power and long battery life. Several shock collars come with a guarantee period, so in my opinion, you should buy those collars. The ease of charging these collars when the battery runs low must also be a considered a major factor.

6) Comfort

You’ll be introducing your four-legged friend to training collars so naturally, they are not comfortable with the idea of having a chunky collar on their necks. Do a thorough research on training collar with respect to the width of your pet’s neck.

Dog Training Collars in 2019 - How to Choose The Best Training Collar?

Prevalence of the best training collars for small dogs and the best training collars for large dogs has left with a pool of choices. So, strive for the most comfortable shock collar.

Keep in mind that pups who are less than six months old should not be wearing training collars. Apart from them, dogs with a history of abuse or susceptibility to anxiety should never wear these shock collars.

Types of Dog Training Collars

Before purchasing a shock collar for your pet, you need to know the types of dog training collars and their purposes:

· Stimulus-Response Training Collar:

This type of dog training collar can be segregated into two sub-sections: Stimulus-response dog collars are created for the purpose of restricting barks or creating an invisible fence for your dog. The similar mechanism of these collars functions by initiating a shock in response to your dog’s undesirable activity that you’re trying to deter. These collars are pre-set to shock your pet when for instance they’ve run past a specific boundary created by you.

· Remote Activated Collars:

In this type of dog training collar, instead of having a pre-set shock setting the owner initiates a shock when he sees fit. This kind of shock collar is used for a general utilization rather than targeting in deterring a specific behavior. You can adjust and customize the shock setting and trigger the collar in real time. This is preferred by pet owners because it gives them more autonomy in the disciplining act.

Top 5 Dog Training Collars

1. Petrainer PET998DBB2 Dog Training CollarPetrainer PET998DBB2 - 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar

This Petrainer model is an easy to understand shock collar with a lot of customized shock settings. It features two waterproof receivers, rainproof transmitters, and an overall water-resistant design. It covers a whopping 330 yards for your furry friend along with several power-saving as well as secure training settings.

Perfect for those pet parents who are not looking for a lot of complications in their dog training collar. The remote transmitter of this shock collar can simultaneously control two dog collars. The Petrainer collar is suitable for almost all sizes of dogs, larger dogs of 15lbs or less as well. Petrainer also features a rechargeable Lithium set of batteries for the transmitters that can be easily charged.

#CommissionsEarned – Shop now


  • 100% Waterproof, and Rainproof Transmitter
  • Can control 2 dog collars
  • Provides a 990ft coverage: decent, given the price point
  • Different Modes: Beep, Vibration, and Shock
  • Contains 100 Levels of Simulation
  • Features 2 Waterproof Receivers
  • User-friendly, simplistic design, ease of installation
  • Power saving design: memory function and automated standby
  • Secure training owing to its Auto-Protect Setting
  • Rechargeable Lithium batteries with an ease of charging
  • Size available for almost all sizes of dogs: adjustable straps
  • Low-light suitable display so it can easily be used at night time
  • Is on the more affordable price range


  • The collar can go in sleep mode involuntarily
  • Can be rarely sensitive to moisture which can result in slight malfunctioning
  • As opposed to other mentions in this list, this product just provides a 990ft coverage which is low

2. PetTech PT0Z1 Dog Training Collar

PetTech PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar

PetTech PT0Z1 is a very viable option for an affordable e-collar. Although the price point is relatively low, the product does not compromise on specifications and features. This 100% waterproof E-Collar provides a transmitter range of 1200 ft which is a decent amount in the given price.

Like all the other great mentions here, this too offers three different modes with 100 customization levels. The rechargeable lithium batteries, power protect the design, and overall ease of installation gives it more points. The universally fitting claim and a backlit LCD are some really good additions to this dog training collar.

#CommissionsEarned – Shop now


  • 100% Waterproof, Rainproof transmitter.
  • Provides a good 1200ft coverage, good given the price point
  • Waterproof E-collar
  • Different Modes: Beep, Vibration, and Shock
  • 100 Levels of Simulation
  • User-friendly, simplistic design, ease of installation
  • Auto Power Protect design: automated standby
  • Rechargeable Lithium-ion batteries
  • Size available for almost all sizes of dogs
  • Low-light suitability with Blue Backlit LCD Display
  • Refund and Replacement Warranty from the manufacturers
  • It falls on the affordable price point relatively


  • Because of its size adjustability, the collar might become loose
  • The design may seem flimsy and cheap
  • Motion sensor does not get deactivated when inactive
  • Switching modes is not as quick as needed
  • Furrier dogs might find it difficult to work with as it is low impact with fur
  • The plastic design can irritate the dog, he may even chew it off

3. SportDOG Brand 425 Dog Training Collar

SportDOG Brand 425 Family Remote Trainers

SportDOG Brand 425 is a slightly pricier dog training collar which gives a good 1500 ft transmitter coverage. The company claims that it is completely waterproof while being able to function even after submerged 25 feet into the water. Such claims are obviously great if your four-legged buddy likes to swim and you have a persistent contact with the water.

However, with just 7 levels of stimulation, the product fails to deliver. With such a small range of levels, the magnitude of shock may seem too much.

On the brighter side, this product features ion batteries that become fully charged in 2 hours and can work for 70 hours. Another great feature of this trainer is the inclusion of many guides and supporting appliances.

#CommissionsEarned – Shop now


  • DryTek Technology: 100% Waterproof, Rainproof transmitter, Can work even when submerged up to 25 feet
  • Can train three dogs with one Remote Transmitter
  • Has a great 1500 ft coverage
  • Contains 3 Different Modes: Tone, Vibration, and Shock
  • 7 Levels of Static Stimulation with a Simultaneous, Continuous Stimulation
  • User-friendly, simplistic design
  • Power saving design: memory function and automated standby
  • Rechargeable Ion Batteries with an ease of charging
  • A charged transmitter can function up to 50 hours
  • Low Battery indicator enabled
  • Comes with three different designs and prices
  • The company offers a detailed guide for operating, DVD manual and customer support for six x days per week
  • Suitable for dry, humid, snowy, rainy weather, etc
  • Comes with a split-end charger


  • Is on a Higher Price Range Relatively
  • Not created for tiny dogs(8 pounds of larger dogs)
  • The shock levels may seem a bit too strong
  • Does not provide enough levels of stimulation

4. Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar

Educator E-Collar Remote is the most expensive mention in this list of 5 products. Although it provides some really good features like additional stimulation, ‘lock and set’ feature for locking the desired stimulation, ‘blunt’ stimulation instead of ‘sharp’ to prevent any discomfort, inclusion of ‘pavlovian tone’ etc.

These features are indeed innovative and effective but there are some massive downsides to this product. Starting with coverage, the transmitter of this training collar covers a painfully low area of 5 ft. Along with no absolutely no claims of being waterproof and a slightly tricky setup.

#CommissionsEarned – Shop now


  • Different Modes: Beep, Vibration, Shock and additional mode
  • Rechargeable Batteries with an ease of charging
  • Features a ‘blunt’ shock instead of ‘sharp’ shock: less stressful and more effective for dogs
  • Features a Pavlovian Tone (Classical Conditioning by Pavlov) to help dogs associated with the deterring
  • Contains a COS (Control of Stimulation) to finely tune stimulation as needed
  • Stimulation levels range from 0-100 levels
  • Contains a ‘lock n set’ feature: users can lock their desired level of stimulation
  • Additional Stimulation for Distraction
  • Claims to be the fastest wireless dog collar
  • Effective in tackling very bad temperamental dogs
  • Made of sturdy and thick material
  • Features low impact stimulation for sensitive dogs


  • The problem of malfunctioning of charger has been noticed
  • Is present on the higher price range
  • Doesn’t claim to be waterproof or withstanding submersion in water
  • The setup can be a little daunting
  • Features a very low range of 5ft, won’t even cover the backyard of your home

5. PetSafe Dog Training Collar

The PetSafe training dog collar is an effective training asset that uses static stimulation technology to impact the dog’s behavior. While this technology is highly effective in training, PetSafe has made sure it is not harmful to the dog by creating low-output static signals that won’t cause any negative effects. This collar is waterproof and has a very sturdy and durable design.

With the ability to operate at wide ranges of distance, this training dog collar is the perfect solution for both indoor and outdoor activities. If you want to manage your dog’s bad behavior while walking or hiking, the PetSafe training dog collar will help you safely train the dog to obey orders and respect certain boundaries. On top of the great technology this device features, it is adjustable and can fit most dogs, no matter their size.

#CommissionsEarned – Shop now


  • With 400 yards of range, this collar can operate even when your dog is far away from you.
  • Both the collar and the remote are rechargeable and you can even recharge both at the same time, using the wall adapter that is included in the price.
  • Besides the durable design, the PetSafe dog collar is waterproof up to 25 feet underwater, which prevents malfunction in case your dog jumps into a pool, lake or any other body of water.
  • As a company of pet-lovers, PetSafe provides the safest training collars on the market, having sold millions of pieces since 1991.
  • The company provides warranty support to US customers who can get in touch with them via email, call or live chat.
  • This PetSafe training collar can be used for both indoor and outdoor training.
  • If you purchase additional PetSafe collars (only one is included in the package) you can train up to three dogs at the same time.
  • The collar features 8 adjustable levels of powerful but safe static stimulation.
  • The stimulation technology eliminates bad behaviors and helps you get the dogs attention easily.
  • The PetSafe company is partnered up with many innovative companies that work together on further improving the pet training technologies.


  • The receiver and the collar may not pair up that easily every time.
  • The device takes way too long to charge, as you may need up to 12 hours to fully charge it.
  • The collar is made of plastic, not comfortable nylon material.

Check Out a Few of These Fantastic Dog Training Collars

Training CollarQualityOur Rating
Petrainer PET998DBB2A
PetTech PT0Z1A-
SportDOG Brand 425
Educator E-CollarB+
PetSafe Training CollarA


After considering all five reviewed dog collars, I personally believe that the fifth product on the list, the PetSafe Dog Training Collar is the most effective solution for controlling the dog’s behavior and teaching him to follow commands at specific times. This collar is highly durable and it won’t break down even if you submerge it 25 feet under water. With eight adjustable levels of static stimulation, you can easily determine to which levels your dog responds best and use them to further progress in training. Overall, if you were to ask me, this training collar seems to be the best choice for dog training, both indoors and outdoors.

#CommissionsEarned – SHOP AT CHEWY.COM

Related Posts

  1. How to Find the Best Low Protein Puppy Food?
  2. Can Dogs Eat Canned Salmon?

Leave Comment

About Us

Aims to be one of the only dedicated dog news sources. This includes dogs in the media, news-worthy events, product recalls, celebrity dogs, and anything else in the news that involves dogs.

Amazon Associates Program is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of, Inc. or its affiliates.
Additionally, participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links.
The website does not intend to provide veterinary advice. We go to great lengths to help users better understand their dogs; however, the content on this blog is not a substitute for veterinary guidance. For more information, please read our: Privacy Policy & Disclaimer.
Privacy & Cookies
This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use. To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Privacy Policy & Disclaimer